The Ordination of Women in the Catholic Church: unmasking a cuckoo’s egg tradition, John Wijngaards Darton, Longman & Todd, £10.95.
by Judith Champ
Dr Judith Champ wrote The English Pilgrimage to Rome (Gracewing 2000). She lectures in Church History at Oscott College, the major seminary for the Catholic Archdiocese of Birmingham (UK).
The chick’s still in the nest

John Wijngaards’s new book is written with passion and commitment, to persuade people to a particular view, yet it seeks to set out a survey of the evidence so as to invite an objective response. Wijngaards asks the reader to be convinced that traditional church teaching against the ordination of women is based largely on the influence of ancient Roman law in the early Church. This baleful influence, which kept women in subjection, was powerful enough to overwhelm the message of Christ in relation to women. He then proceeds to demolish, in a lucid, lively and persuasive book, the other key arguments against the ordination of women. He leaves us with the conclusion that the continued ban has no authentic roots in Christian tradition, but results from the perpetuation of base, pagan prejudice.
This trenchant view is unsurprising from an author who has associated himself with the movement for the ordination of women since the 1970s, and recently gave up his active ministry as a Mill Hill Father in protest at the continued ban, The book will reinforce and support those who advocate the ordination of women, and will introduce others to a range of opinions expressed by medieval canonists and theologians such as Thomas Aquinas, Bonaventure, Richard of Middleton, Duns Scotus and Durandus of Saint-Pourcain who are quoted approvingly by Rome. It may well convince “those who instinctively feel that women should be ordained”. The difficulty is that while it sets out its objective as being to “unnerve the traditional arguments against ordaining women”, it also claims to “take all sections of the Catholic community seriously, including those who accept Rome’s view uncritically because they feel it is their duty to do so”. I fear that these two propositions are incompatible.
The “cuckoo’s egg” of the title refers to the practice in the natural world of cuckoos laying eggs in other birds’ nests, which eventually hatch, drive out the other fledglings and convince the foster parent birds to feed their illegitimate offspring. In Wijngaards’s view, the practice of excluding women from ordination is just such a spurious and damaging “cuckoo’s egg” in the tradition of the Church. The Church’s leaders have became wrongly convinced that the ban on ordaining women is, in fact, their authentic chick. The metaphor is a tempting one, and the author labours it heavily in the opening and closing chapters: “Understandably, perhaps, popes consider themselves first and foremost guardians of tradition. And tradition is judged by what has been done in the Church throughout the centuries, without examining the credentials of the practice. It is as if church leaders in this way become ‘bonded’ to the practice, not unlike host birds becoming bonded to the cuckoo chick.”
The author goes on to pursue this throughout, by gathering texts to show that the practice is a false reflection of the Gospel and of the true tradition of the Church, which has its roots in the Imperial Roman law and culture which heavily influenced that of the emergent Christian Church. The later chapters work systematically through the main reasons adduced in the past and present for not ordaining women, none of which are regarded as authentic. The arguments found in tradition which underpin current papal teaching are summed up in five propositions: that women are not created in the image of God as men are, but are created as subservient to men; women still carry the burden of Eve’s sin; Christ did not include a woman among the apostolic twelve; women are not allowed to teach in church; women are not perfect human beings and thus cannot represent Christ.
According to Wijngaards, in still regarding women as imperfectly able to represent Christ, and in still preventing women from teaching in church, Rome rests its position mainly on a false reading of Jesus’ activities. In other words, the Church is still trapped by a tradition based on the continuity of Roman law In church law. Wijngaards argues that this is the reason for the consistent “view from Rome”. Yet many of the supporting traits he cites come not from Rome but from theologians lui various parts of the Church. Where is the context in which these views are expressed? Besides Roman law and culture, complex religious and cultural interactions were operating which are not brought out in this discussion.
The ordained ministry took its specific form only after centuries, and has continued to be reinterpreted wherever the Church has taken root. If the whole tradition is dismissed as spurious and false, any debate is driven up a blind alley. By dismissing the argument evinced by Rome as self-evidently wrong-headed, Wijngaards effectively closes off the possibility of dialogue as much as the position of the present papacy does.
The presentation is articulate and persuasive and the passionate commitment of the author is crystal clear. Were the issue less contentious, however, and the passions less committed, would the arguments stand up to rigorous historical scrutiny? Does the appeal to a sleight of hand based on Roman law really bear all the weight which Wijngaards puts on it?
Judith Champ
Further information on the book:
